The Pittsburgh Steelers’ 2024 campaign was a rollercoaster of early promise and late-season disappointment. Starting with a 10–3 record, the team seemed poised for a deep playoff run.
However, a four-game losing streak to close the regular season, culminating in a 28–14 Wild Card loss to the Baltimore Ravens, extended their postseason win drought to eight seasons. Early playoff exits has become a recurring theme under head coach Mike Tomlin, who continues to have winning seasons despite the adversity his team has faced. Here’s a look back at last year’s highs and lows and what we can expect as the team tries to turn it’s fortunes around entering next week’s NFL Draft.
A season of highs and lows
The Steelers began the season with Justin Fields at quarterback, securing a 4-2 record during his six starts. Fields’ performance peaked in Week 3 when he threw 245 yards and a touchdown, plus added a rushing touchdown against the Los Angeles Chargers. Fields completed 78% of his 32 attempts in that game, but would start to cool off despite a Week 4 high of 315 passing yards. The Steelers would fall to the Colts and Cowboys before a 145-yard performance sealed Fields’ fate.
Inconsistency led to a midseason switch to Russell Wilson, who provided a temporary boost as the offense improved by 10 points per game and gained over 100 yards of production. Wilson’s standout performance came in Week 13 against the Bengals, throwing for 414 yards in a 44-38 victory. Despite these flashes, the offense struggled late in the season with the passing game ranking 27th in the league with 192.0 yards per game.
The defense remained a strong point, finishing 8th in points allowed (20.4 per game). T.J. Watt led the team with 11.5 sacks, while linebacker Patrick Queen contributed 129 tackles. Teryl Austin’s unit also led the NFL in forced turnovers. Yet, the defense would also falter late in the season, allowing the Eagles to run 47 plays in the second half, relinquished 348 yards to Derrick Henry alone in two games, and gave up over 27 points during the final five game skid.
Offseason changes and challenges
This offseason brought significant roster changes for the Steelers. The quarterback room has turned over with Fields and Wilson signing with the New York Jets and Giants respectively. Running back Najee Harris, wide receiver Mike Williams, and cornerback Donte Jackson also left, joining the Los Angeles Chargers. Starting guard James Daniels signed with the Dolphins while starting tackle Dan Moore Jr. signed with the Titans.
The via free agency additions have been minimal, leaving the returning Mason Rudolph and former Dolphin Skylar Thompson as their primary quarterbacks, raising concerns about the team’s offensive capabilities.
Much of the offseason buzz around Pittsburgh has been tied to veteran quarterback Aaron Rodgers, who was released by the Jets. Rodgers visited the team for a full day nearly a month ago. The Steelers’ interest in Rodgers became one of the most talked-about storylines in the latest NFL news, with speculation about how his arrival could reshape the team’s short-term future.
Rodgers was also recently spotted participating in a workout with wide receiver D.K. Metcalf, who was acquired in a blockbuster trade with the Seahawks. Metcalf was the crown jewel of Pittsburgh’s offseason, but the question remains as to who is throwing the ball to him and his maligned counterpart, George Pickens.
While team owner Art Rooney II expressed optimism about signing Rodgers, the quarterback’s decision remains pending. The uncertainty of the quarterback position has become a focal point for the team’s offseason strategy.
Draft strategy and future outlook
With the 21st overall pick in the 2025 NFL Draft, the Steelers have several pressing needs. The departure of key players has created gaps in the roster, particularly at quarterback, running back, and defensive tackle.
The team has shown interest in top quarterback prospects, including Shedeur Sanders, Jaxson Dart, and Jalen Milroe, indicating a potential move to secure a long-term solution at the position. They have also hosted Louisville’s Tyler Shough and Syracuse’s Kyle McCord for pre-draft visits.
Defensively, the team is looking to bolster the line, especially with veteran Cameron Heyward nearing the end of his career. One potential target is Derrick Harmon, a defensive tackle from Oregon, who has impressed scouts with his versatility and pass-rushing abilities. (Harmon recently visited the team too.)
The uncertainty around the Steelers’ draft direction has already made them a popular subject in early NFL picks and offseason predictions. Fans and analysts alike are speculating how a new quarterback or a high-impact defensive addition could alter the team’s trajectory heading into 2025. The AFC North is already competitive with quarterbacks Lamar Jackson and Joe Burrow having led their teams to AFC Championship games in recent years.
With a slate against the AFC East and NFC North, plus a historic game in Dublin, Ireland, these games will test the team’s adaptability and resilience as they navigate a challenging season.
Building a Path Forward
The Steelers’ consistent regular-season success under Tomlin is commendable, but the lack of postseason victories has become a point of contention among fans and analysts. The team’s ability to address key roster gaps, particularly at quarterback, will be crucial in determining their trajectory for the upcoming season.
Will it be Rodgers, a rookie, or Rudolph at the helm in 2025? And if the quarterback position is mitigated, how might that factor into the Steelers strategy against higher-powered offenses such as the the two Super Bowl teams they faced during their five-game losing streak last season?
The acquisition of DK Metcalf adds a dynamic element to the offense, potentially providing a deep-threat option lacking in previous seasons. Metcalf’s presence should open the field for Pickens and TE Pat Freiermuth too. However, the effectiveness of this addition hinges on the team’s ability to solidify the quarterback position. After all, it’s the most important position in football.
Yet, Coach Tomlin has weathered these storms before. He got the most out of a post-injury, aging Ben Roethlisberger and somehow maintained his controversial, albeit flawless regular season streak with lesser talents playing quarterback. If Tomlin could win with Mitch Trubisky, Kenny Pickett, Mason Rudolph, Duck Hodges, Justin Fields and Russell Wilson, who’s to say he can’t pull a rabbit out of his hat and surprise us once again in 2025?
Steelers put 2024 in their rearview as they enter the NFL Draft and offseason appeared first on Steel City Underground.