In the past few years, fans of the National Football League – who vote for players to be sent to the annual All-Star game, now games – have become disillusioned by how the league has taken away what used to be an honor: being named a Pro Bowler. With recent changes for the upcoming Pro Bowl Games, the NFL may have just killed-off any hopes of resurrection of fan interest, and investment, in what has become more of an exhibition of silliness rather real competition.
The changes that led up to current disaster
Longtime NFL fans remember when players named to the Pro Bowl used to be the top stars among all players in the league. It was a badge of honor to have Pro Bowlers on the historical record of teams. Those days, sadly, are gone.
When the league decided to make the event a skills competition (try not to smirk) as players casually got together like they were at a backyard picnic, adding a flag football game as an event screamed of unseriousness. As Joe Kuzma wrote in 2023:
“Fans still panned the game, which saw all of the Super Bowl participants bow out now… Less than worthy alternates filled in for those star players, as the game continued to devolve into anything but a competition.”
Why the league continues to ask fans to vote when the players they vote for often choose not to show up is even more discouraging. It undermines the whole point: sending players to an event with any real meaning. And, it’s not lost on fans that the process has become something of a sham.
A final death toll?
The bell may have just rung the loudest it ever has as teams began announcing that replacements were being sent in place of others who had opted out, and the opt-outs weren’t just players who were headed to the Super Bowl who were preparing for the big game.
The latest drop-out, Lamar Jackson, just lost a playoff game and remains in the running for NFL MVP for the 2024 NFL season. In his stead, the league chose Russell Wilson. That’s fun for Wilson fans (some who will also be Pittsburgh Steelers backers), but it has fans – in general – asking how he was selected over other potential quarterbacks. The AFC will now be represented by Wilson, Joe Burrow, and Drake Maye.
Maye started in 12 games for the New England Patriots went 3-9 with him at quarterback; his rank among all NFL QBs (2024 regular season) 17th per ESPN stats. Burrow ranked 3rd, which is respectable, but Wilson ranked 22nd.
Did fan voting totals factor into how the replacements are chosen? Did Wilson have more votes than Justin Herbert (rated 11th) for example? How exactly does the system even work anymore?
The original AFC Pro Bowl roster at quarterback was Josh Allen, Jackson, and Burrow, for perspective.
Every media outlet has been informed that the original roster should be considered in flux. That means it has become apparent that the NFL’s choices surrounding the All Star event aren’t transparent. The moves are alienating fans, by fans’ own admissions across social media, that they’re apt to just boycott the games to send a message to the league.
The scheduled events are almost laughable
With Eli and Peyton Manning as the “coaches” representing the NFC and AFC, respectively, the first half of the week the “skill” competitions will take place. “The Big Spike” sounds like an attempt to imitate the NBA’s slam dunk competition, but is spiking a football a skill worth watching? What in the world is “Helmet Harmony”?! Will professional football players play a match game while holding a cold beer or singing Kumbaya? How are helmets harmonious? And let’s not forget “Satisfying Catches.” I think fans wish they could see more than just something satisfying at such a heralded event.
The second half of the festivities – that used to be a serious game of true All Stars battling for the chance to earn a win that mattered for their conference – will feature a game, at least. It will be a 7-on-7 flag football match, of course, where players dress in random attire (including sunglasses and sweats) and goof around. A win is like being the victor at the family Thanksgiving game after dinner at grandma and grandpa’s.
The EA Sports Madden NFL 25 Challenge, Punt Perfect, Great Football Race, and Tug-of-War round out the Pro Bowl Games this year.
Let’s just call the Pro Bowl Games what it truly has become: a chance for NFL players to hang out in a chill environment with other players and have a good time.
The NFL has not improved their image of competitive football with the switch between what the Pro Bowl was to what the Pro Bowl Games are. They’ve come up with a gimmick, and fans aren’t pleased.
The NFL may have just killed-off the Pro Bowl forever appeared first on Steel City Underground.